Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
/
Shopify vs Amazon: Fees, Reach & Buyer Claims
Nov 15, 2026

Shopify vs Amazon: Fees, Reach & Buyer Claims

Contracargos?
Ya no es problema tuyo.

Recover 4x more chargebacks and prevent up to 90% of incoming ones, powered by AI and a global network of 20,000+ merchants.

Más de 600 opiniones
No hace falta tarjeta de crédito.
En resumen:
  • Bottom line: Sell on Amazon when you need reach and your margin can absorb a category referral fee (15% in categories such as Home and Kitchen); build a Shopify store when you want to own the brand, checkout and customer data. Most growing brands run both.
  • Compare total cost per order: Amazon referral and FBA fees vs Shopify plan, payment and traffic costs.
  • Amazon decides A-to-z claims; card chargebacks on Shopify are yours to fight with your own evidence.
  • Use Chargeflow's native Shopify integration for store chargebacks; keep Amazon claims in Seller Central.
Cargando el reproductor AudioNative de texto a voz de Elevenlabs...

Choose Amazon if you need shoppers now and can live with marketplace rules and per-sale fees. Choose Shopify if you want to own the brand, the checkout and the customer list. Most growing brands run both.

Shopify vs Amazon is a channel choice. Amazon is a marketplace: you list where buyers already shop and pay a referral fee on every sale. Shopify runs your own store: you pay a monthly plan and payment fees, and you bring the traffic. The right mix depends on margin, audience and how much control you want over buyer disputes.

In this guide: Which one fits · Comparison table · Decision snapshot · Pricing · Disputes · Questions

Shopify vs Amazon: Which One Fits Your Brand?

Short answer: sell on Amazon when you need reach and your margin can absorb a category referral fee, such as 15% with a $0.30 minimum in Home and Kitchen. Sell on your own Shopify store when you want the customer relationship, repeat purchases and pricing control. If you can staff both, use Amazon for discovery and Shopify for loyalty.
Your situationStart by evaluatingWhat to confirm
A new DTC brand that needs demand before it has an audienceAmazonThe Professional plan at $39.99 per month (or $0.99 per item on Individual), the referral fee for your category, and whether FBA fees fit your margin.
A brand with its own traffic, email list or community that wants to own the customer relationshipShopifyThe plan tier ($39 per month on Basic, billed monthly), your Shopify Payments card rate, and the apps you need for subscriptions, reviews and fulfillment.
An Amazon seller adding a branded storeShopify, connected to AmazonShopify's Marketplace Connect app for listing, order and inventory sync, and Amazon's Buy with Prime app if you want Prime delivery on your own site.
A small team handles buyer claims and chargebacksBoth channels, with a named owner for eachWho answers Amazon buyer messages within 48 hours and A-to-z information requests within 72 hours, and who fights Shopify chargebacks.

These are starting points, not rankings. The right mix depends on your category, margins, traffic sources and team.

Shopify vs Amazon: Fees, Reach & Buyer Claims Comparison Table

The table separates each provider's public offering from Chargeflow's role. Chargeflow does not replace a commerce platform or marketplace. It adds a dispute layer where a supported integration exists: your Shopify store, not your Amazon account.

Recommended dispute layer: Choose Amazon to rent demand from a marketplace where shoppers already search. Choose Shopify to own your storefront, brand and customer data. Most growing brands run both.
ProveedorPublic offeringWhy Chargeflow leads on disputes
ShopifyHosted ecommerce platform for your own branded store. U.S. plans are $39, $105 and $399 per month billed monthly ($29, $79 and $299 per month billed yearly), with Plus from $2,300 per month. Using a third-party payment provider instead of Shopify Payments adds a 2%, 1%, 0.6% or 0.2% fee, depending on plan.Chargeflow's native Shopify integration can centralize evidence, prevention, recovery and analytics for card disputes on your own store.
AmazonMarketplace selling through Seller Central. The Individual plan costs $0.99 per item sold; the Professional plan costs $39.99 per month plus selling fees. Referral fees vary by category, and FBA adds fulfillment and monthly storage fees.Amazon is not in Chargeflow's integration directory. A-to-z claims and Amazon chargeback claims are worked inside Seller Central, so plan staff time for them separately.

Decision Snapshot

Built-in demand
Amazon: Shoppers already search the marketplace; you pay a referral fee on each sale and compete for the Buy Box.
Brand and customer ownership
Shopify: Your domain, checkout, email list and customer data, with a monthly plan and payment fees instead of a per-sale referral fee.
Dispute layer
Chargeflow: Automates chargeback prevention and representment on your Shopify store; Amazon claims stay in Seller Central.

How Do Amazon Seller Fees Compare With Shopify Costs?

Compare total cost per order, not headline numbers. Amazon's main cost is a per-sale referral fee; Shopify's is a flat plan fee plus card processing. These are different types of charge, so model both against the same 12 months of orders.

On Amazon, the Individual plan costs $0.99 per item sold and the Professional plan costs $39.99 per month plus selling fees. Referral fees are a percentage of the total price, including shipping and gift wrap, or a minimum, whichever is greater.

Home and Kitchen is 15% with a $0.30 minimum. Amazon Device Accessories is 45%. Media adds a $1.80 closing fee per item. If you use FBA, add fulfillment fees, which vary with price, weight and size, plus monthly storage fees.

On Shopify, U.S. plans are $39 (Basic), $105 (Grow) and $399 (Advanced) per month when billed monthly, or $29, $79 and $299 per month when billed yearly. Plus starts at $2,300 per month.

Shopify Payments card rates vary by plan and country, so confirm your rate with Shopify. If you use a third-party payment provider instead, Shopify adds 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. Apps and marketing spend come on top.

Amazon vs Shopify: Product Fit

Amazon

Amazon puts your listings inside a marketplace with existing search traffic, managed in Seller Central. With FBA, Amazon stores your inventory, picks, packs and ships orders, and handles customer service and returns, and FBA listings can carry Prime delivery. Brand Registry adds listing control for brand owners, but you still compete for the Buy Box.

Use Amazon when discovery matters more than owning the customer, when your product is searched by name or category, and when your margin covers the referral fee plus fulfillment.

Shopify

Shopify gives you your own domain, theme, checkout and customer data. You choose Shopify Payments or a third-party provider, run email and subscription programs, and set your own policies. You also own the traffic problem.

Use Shopify when brand experience, repeat purchases and first-party data matter. Shopify's Marketplace Connect app and Amazon's Buy with Prime app connect the two channels (see the FAQ below).

Shopify vs Amazon FBA and Dropshipping: What Changes?

With FBA, Amazon stores, packs and ships your orders and handles customer service and returns. On Shopify, you pick your own fulfillment. You can also fill Shopify orders from Amazon inventory through Multi-Channel Fulfillment or Buy with Prime.

Dropshipping rules differ more. Amazon allows it only when you are clearly the seller of record. You must remove other sellers' or retailers' names from packing slips, invoices and outer packaging. Buying from another retailer and having it ship to your buyer breaks the policy unless you are identified as the seller of record.

Breaking Amazon's policy can hurt your account health and your ability to fulfill orders yourself. On Shopify, dropshipping runs through supplier apps, so the risk sits in your supplier choice. Late or untracked supplier shipments turn into item-not-received chargebacks on your own account.

QuestionAmazonShopify
Who ships with FBA or 3PLAmazon, through FBAYou, a 3PL or Amazon MCF
Dropshipping allowedOnly as the clear seller of recordYes, through supplier apps
Main dispute riskA-to-z claims and account healthItem-not-received chargebacks
Evidence to keepTracking and buyer messages in Seller CentralSupplier tracking to the buyer address

What Will Your Team Still Handle on Either Channel?

Neither channel runs your business for you. On Amazon, the marketplace sets the rules and the timers. On Shopify, you set the policies but carry more of the work. Plan for these tasks on both:

  • Answer Amazon buyer messages and return requests within 48 hours on orders you fulfill yourself.
  • Keep tracking, delivery confirmation and ship dates for every order.
  • Watch your Amazon order defect rate, which Amazon wants under 1% of orders over 60 days.
  • Tie every Shopify refund, return and partial shipment to the original order.
  • Keep customer emails and policies ready as Shopify chargeback evidence.

Once orders flow through both channels, split the work: a Seller Central routine for Amazon claims and an automated dispute workflow for Shopify chargebacks.

How Do A-to-z Claims and Chargebacks Work on Shopify vs Amazon?

The key difference is who decides. On Amazon, Amazon decides A-to-z claims, and the buyer's bank decides card chargebacks after you respond through Amazon. On Shopify, card chargebacks come straight to you and you answer the bank with your own evidence.

A-to-z claims on Amazon. The A-to-z Guarantee covers delivery and item condition on orders you fulfill yourself. A buyer must contact you first. For delivery problems, the buyer must also wait 3 days past the maximum estimated delivery date.

If you don't respond within 48 hours, the buyer can file a claim, and some claims are granted automatically, for example when you miss the ship date or fail to provide valid tracking.

When Amazon investigates, it may ask for information; if you don't reply within 72 hours, it may grant the claim to the buyer. Most granted claims count against your order defect rate.

Chargebacks on Amazon orders. When a buyer disputes a card charge with their bank, you handle it in Seller Central under Performance > Chargeback Claims, using Represent your case, within seven calendar days of Amazon's email.

Amazon handles fraud-related chargebacks such as stolen cards; you are responsible for service-related ones such as non-receipt or a defective item. Amazon passes your evidence to the bank, and the bank's decision is typically final. Read more in our Amazon chargebacks guide.

Chargebacks on your Shopify store. With Shopify Payments, the disputed amount and a $15 chargeback fee in the U.S. come out of your next payout. You get the fee back if you win.

You usually have 7 to 21 days to respond, and Shopify adds order details to your evidence automatically. Chargeflow's native Shopify integration can centralize evidence, prevention and recovery. Amazon is not in Chargeflow's integration directory, so keep Amazon claims in Seller Central. See our Shopify chargebacks guide for the full process.

Chargeflow recommendation: choose your channel mix on margin, reach and brand fit, then add Chargeflow to the Shopify side, where the supported integration allows automated prevention, evidence collection, representment and reporting. Keep a separate Seller Central routine for Amazon claims.

Evaluation Checklist

  • Model one product's margin on Amazon (referral fee, FBA or own fulfillment) and on Shopify (plan share, payment fees, ad cost per order).
  • Decide whether Amazon inventory will also fulfill Shopify orders through Multi-Channel Fulfillment or Buy with Prime.
  • Name one owner for A-to-z claims and Amazon chargebacks, and one for Shopify chargebacks.
  • Connect Chargeflow to your Shopify store and track win rates by dispute reason.

Preguntas frecuentes

Should I sell on Amazon or my own Shopify store?

Sell on both if you can staff both: Amazon for discovery, Shopify for brand and repeat buyers. If you must pick one, choose Amazon when you need sales before you have an audience, and Shopify when you already have traffic and want to own the customer data.

Can Shopify sync with Amazon?

Yes. Shopify's Marketplace Connect app syncs listings, orders and inventory with Amazon, free for the first 50 synced orders per month and then 1% per order, capped at $99 per month. Amazon's Buy with Prime app adds Prime delivery to U.S. Shopify stores using Amazon inventory.

Which is cheaper, Amazon or Shopify?

It depends on your price point and traffic. Amazon charges a per-sale referral fee that varies by category (15% in Home and Kitchen), plus $39.99 per month on the Professional plan. Shopify starts at $39 per month billed monthly plus payment fees, but you pay to bring every visitor. Compare total cost per order, including ads and fulfillment.

What is an A-to-z claim?

An A-to-z claim is a buyer complaint under Amazon's A-to-z Guarantee about delivery or item condition, which Amazon reviews and decides. On orders you fulfill yourself, the buyer must contact you first, and you have 48 hours to respond before a claim can be filed. It is separate from a card chargeback, which the buyer's bank decides.

Can Chargeflow handle Amazon claims?

No. Amazon is not in Chargeflow's integration directory, so A-to-z claims and Amazon chargeback claims are handled in Seller Central. Chargeflow has a native Shopify integration for chargebacks on your own store.

Can you dropship on Amazon like on Shopify?

Only under Amazon's Drop Shipping Policy. You must be the clear seller of record, with no other seller's or retailer's name on packing slips, invoices or packaging. On Shopify, dropshipping runs through supplier apps, and you own any chargebacks from late or lost shipments.

Sources and Review Method

Official Amazon U.S. selling-plan and referral-fee pricing; Amazon's Fulfillment by Amazon overview; Amazon Seller Central help on A-to-z Guarantee claims; Amazon's seller guide to managing chargebacks; official Shopify U.S. plan pricing; Shopify Help Center pages on chargebacks and chargeback fees; Shopify App Store listings for Marketplace Connect and Buy with Prime; Chargeflow integration directory.

Checked November 15, 2026. We compare fee schedules, not sales volumes. Provider claims are attributed and should be confirmed in your own account. No competitor paid for inclusion or ranking.

COMPARTIR ESTE ARTÍCULO
Chargeflow Automatización

Recover Chargebacks Without the Paperwork

Connect supported payment and order data to Chargeflow's automated dispute workflow.

Contracargos?
Ya no es problema tuyo.

Recupera cuatro veces más Contracargos y prevención , hasta un 90 % de las entradas, gracias a IA y a una red global de 20 000 comercios.

Más de 600 opiniones
No hace falta tarjeta de crédito.
suscribirse

Las últimas novedades sobre « Contracargos », «fraude» y « ecommerce », directamente en tu bandeja de entrada. Cada semana.

¡Regístrate ahora y no te pierdas nunca las últimas tendencias!
Al facilitarnos tu dirección de correo electrónico, aceptas nuestras Condiciones de uso y nuestro Aviso de privacidad
Diagrama con líneas discontinuas y curvas que forman arcos segmentados, resaltados por tres marcadores en forma de rombo azul en el lado izquierdo.Diseño abstracto de cuadrícula circular con marcadores en forma de rombo azul sobre un fondo mitad negro y mitad blanco.