Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
Limited time BFCM offer for prevent 2.0
/
Fraud Prevention
May 3, 2023
Nov 18, 2026

Refund Fraud: What It Is, Common Types and How Merchants Prevent It

White circular logo with interlocking shapes at the center surrounded by overlapping orbit-like elliptical lines and scattered blue diamond shapes.

Chargebacks?
No longer your problem.

Recover 4x more chargebacks and prevent up to 90% of incoming ones, powered by AI and a global network of 20,000+ merchants.

600+ reviews
No credit card needed.
Refund Fraud: What It Is, Common Types and How Merchants Prevent It

TL;DR:

  • Refund fraud starts with a claim for money the customer knows they are not owed.
  • US retailers forecast $849.9 billion in returns for 2025. Separately, the NRF study put fraud at 9% of returns.
  • Check return tracking, item identity and condition before releasing a high-risk refund.
  • If a bank dispute opens, check for a credit first. Use the case to document what you already paid.
Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

Refund fraud happens when someone claims a refund they know they are not owed. Match the claim to the order and check what came back before you release the money.

What the Retail Returns Figures Measure

In their 2025 US retail study, the National Retail Federation and Happy Returns put return fraud at 9% of all returns in 2025.

$849.9B
Estimated value of US retail returns in 2025
9%
Share of returns reported as fraudulent in the 2025 US study
~45%
Share of global merchant chargebacks attributed to first- or third-party fraud in 2025
$5.13
Total cost to a US retailer for every $1 lost to fraud

Sources: NRF and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape; Mastercard (updated June 2026), first-party and third-party fraud combined; LexisNexis True Cost of Fraud Study, retail and ecommerce, June 2026.

A false return and a bank dispute need different records. Chargeflow can help you respond when a claim reaches the bank.

Scroll to see all columns.
TypeHow it worksFirst check
Friendly fraudThe cardholder disputes a valid purchase with their bank to get the money back.Delivery proof, login and device history, prior orders
Return fraudThe buyer returns an item they did not buy, or a broken or different item, for a full refund.Serial numbers, return photos, receipt match
WardrobingThe buyer uses an item briefly, then returns it as if unused.Tag and condition checks at intake
Item swappingThe buyer sends back a cheaper or older item in the original packaging.Weight, serial number and packaging checks
Employee refund fraudStaff issue refunds without a matching sale or return.Refund approval limits and audit logs
Chargeback threatsThe buyer threatens a dispute to pressure the merchant into an unearned refund.Order evidence on file before you decide

How refund fraud differs from related terms:

  • Refund abuse is misuse of a refund policy that may not be clearly criminal, such as serial or exaggerated claims.
  • Forced refund fraud is abuse of a merchant's own refund process. It needs a different investigation from a cardholder dispute.
  • Digital shoplifting is keeping an online order while getting the money back through a false refund claim or chargeback.

Friendly fraud is when a cardholder disputes a valid purchase with a made-up reason to get their money back. Return fraud is different. Here the customer returns an item they did not buy, or a damaged item, for a full refund.

A customer may threaten a chargeback while asking for a refund. Check the order and your policy before you decide.

What merchants report

One digital product seller posted on X in 2023 that he refunded a customer even though a digital product cannot be returned. His reason: sellers fear chargebacks, and he felt card issuers side with buyers almost every time.

{{cta}}

Understanding Refund Fraud: How Fraudsters Rip off Sellers

Find out what you can verify before a refund goes out. Your order, delivery and return records can also help prevent chargebacks.

Here is a common pattern. A fraudster buys a product or service, then asks for a refund. The claim is usually "order not received" or "item not as described."

You may suspect a lie but approve the refund anyway, to keep the customer happy and protect your reviews. That gap is what fraudsters exploit. They get refunds for orders they received or items they damaged on purpose. Some even pay with stolen card details in the first place.

Fake IDs and throwaway email addresses make this easier online. A fraudster can request a refund and vanish, which makes them hard to trace. The same playbook also runs across web, app and store channels, which is why omnichannel fraud is hard to spot from one system alone.

Watch out for these refund fraud patterns and red flags so you do not become an easy target.

Refund fraud red flags to check before you approve

  • A "not received" claim on an order with carrier proof of delivery
  • A new account, throwaway email or mismatched billing and shipping details
  • Several refund or dispute claims from the same customer, device or address
  • Heavy use of a digital product (downloads, logins) before a refund request
  • A return that weighs less than the item sold or has the wrong serial number
  • A refund request paired with a threat to call the bank

What merchants report

A stock photo seller noted in 2023 that most buyers who disputed or asked for refunds had already downloaded large numbers of photos. Usage data like this is strong evidence when you decide whether to refund or fight.

Types of Refund Fraud to Watch Out For

Spotting refund fraud is mostly pattern recognition. Learn these five types of refund fraud to limit revenue loss, damage to your brand and the risk of losing your processing account.

#1: Friendly Fraud

Friendly fraud happens when a customer disputes a valid charge with their card issuer. They often claim they did not approve it or that it was fraud. Tools like real-time chargeback alerts help catch disputes before they escalate.

Some customers file a dispute even after you refund them; see receiving a chargeback after a refund.

Here are some numbers:

  • First-party and third-party fraud together made up around 45% of merchant chargeback volume worldwide in 2025, per Mastercard (updated June 2026, research by Datos Insights).
  • Mastercard projects about 286 million chargebacks in 2026, with the global cost rising from $36.9 billion in 2026 to $46.1 billion in 2029.
  • US retail and ecommerce firms lose about $5.13 for every $1 of direct fraud loss once fees, labor and lost goods are counted, per the LexisNexis True Cost of Fraud Study (June 2026).

These figures show why friendly fraud needs a defense plan, not just case-by-case refunds.

What merchants report

One seller described frequent disputed purchases on X in 2023. Another reported disputes soon after refund requests. These examples describe two sellers’ experiences.

#2: Return Fraud

A buyer commits return fraud when they trick you into refunding a purchase. They may send back the wrong item or keep the goods after an early refund.

Common methods include:

  • Changing or moving price tags
  • Returning an item bought elsewhere for less
  • Returning a different product than the one sold

Refund Issued, Item Never Received

Visa’s Fall 2026 report describes a buyer who paid with a virtual card, got a refund and kept the goods. You can choose when to release a refund based on the risk of the return.

  • Immediate refund. Use it when your policy lets the buyer keep the item or you can absorb the loss.
  • Refund at the first carrier scan. Check that the carrier has the parcel. A printed label alone does not show that the parcel shipped.
  • Refund after inspection. For a high-value return, match the item and its condition to the order before issuing the refund. Follow the refund deadline that applies to the sale.

Return fraud costs merchants money and can hurt their reputation. Automating chargeback recovery can win back revenue that would otherwise stay lost.

Honest mistakes cause returns too. But industry data shows return fraud is common. Take a look at the stats:

Return fraud types reported by large US retailers that track them (2025)
Overstated quantity of items returned
71%
Empty boxes or "box of rocks" returns
65%
Decoy returns, such as counterfeits
64%

Source: NRF and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape. Survey of 358 ecommerce professionals at US merchants with over $500 million in revenue.

Returns peak after the holidays. See holiday return and refund fraud for a refund-or-fight decision table, policy wording and the evidence to keep.

#3: Wardrobing

Wardrobing is when a shopper buys a product, uses it for a short time, then returns it for a full refund. Clothing is the classic case. The buyer wears it, then says it did not fit or was not right.

Wardrobing is a form of first-party fraud. It costs sales and strains the supply chain, because used items cannot be resold at full price.

Here are some numbers:

  • Close to two-thirds of consumers admit to at least one costly returns habit, including wardrobing and "bracketing" (buying several sizes to return most of them).
  • 45% of consumers say "bending the truth" is acceptable when returning items.
  • Shoppers aged 18 to 30 made 7.7 online returns on average over 12 months, more than any other age group.

Source for all three: NRF and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape (survey of 2,006 US consumers, summer 2025).

#4: Refund Fraud by Employee

Employee refund fraud is when a staff member abuses access to the refund or return system for personal gain. They may create fraudulent refunds or push through returns without approval. A structured approach to chargeback management keeps disputes under control.

The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) estimates that organizations lose 5% of annual revenue to occupational fraud. It classes fake refunds as a register disbursement scheme. Its 2024 Report to the Nations found a median loss of $145,000 per case across 1,921 cases.

Three ways to limit staff refund abuse:

  • Refund approval limits, with a second sign-off above a set amount
  • Audit logs that tie every refund to an order and a staff login
  • Regular reviews of refunds issued per employee

#5: Item Swapping

Item swapping is a form of return fraud. The customer buys an item, swaps it for a cheaper or older one, and returns the swapped item for a full refund. They keep or resell the better product.

Common swaps include:

  • Returning an older item they already own in the new item's box
  • Buying a similar-looking item and moving the tags or packaging
  • Using the new item for a while, then returning a cheaper copy

For electronics, check the serial number on the device as well as the box.

What merchants report

A retail worker posted on X in 2023 that fraudsters buy real AirPods and Apple Watches, then return clones in the real box with the correct serial number barcode. Staff are meant to check the serial on the device itself, but in a rush it is easy to skip.

Item swapping is hard to catch when the swapped item has the same size and weight. It is also costly. The merchant must sell the swapped item at a discount or pay to dispose of it.

See the full chargeback fraud prevention guide for a checklist.

How Does Refund Fraud Impact Businesses?

Refund fraud causes direct losses, harms the brand and creates extra work. It hits on several fronts:

  • Profit: fraudulent refunds drain cash and margin, which hurts small businesses on thin budgets most.
  • Trust: frequent refund fraud erodes customer trust and costs future sales.
  • Honest customers: it leads to stricter return rules and longer wait times for everyone.
  • Prices: businesses pass fraud costs on through higher prices or fewer products.

Those higher prices cut buyers' purchasing power. Some shoppers turn to less suitable options. At a wider level, refund fraud also:

  • reduces market efficiency,
  • disrupts supply networks, and
  • results in the loss of jobs and tax revenue.

Preventing refund fraud is a balancing act. Retailers who push too hard face a backlash. Asos made headlines in April 2019 when it tightened its returns policy. Many customers were offended by its warning: "if we notice an unusual pattern, we might investigate and take action."

The next section covers prevention steps you can apply right away. The wider goal is to prevent eCommerce chargebacks across the store.

Tips for Preventing Refund Fraud

Refund fraud prevention works best in layers. No single control stops every scheme, so match each control to the fraud type it blocks. The standard checklist for preventing refund fraud is:

  1. Verify customer identities
  2. Train employees on fraud patterns
  3. Establish transparent order refund policies
  4. Develop a comprehensive fraud prevention plan
  5. Use advanced fraud detection & mitigation technologies
  6. Use reverse logistics to quality-assure transaction processes
Scroll to see all columns.
ControlStopsEnough on its own when
Verify customer identitiesStolen cards, throwaway accountsFraud comes mostly from new accounts
Train employeesItem swaps at intake, employee refund fraudYou run stores or a returns warehouse
Clear refund policyWardrobing, serial returners, chargeback threatsAbuse is low and claims are mostly honest
Fraud prevention planRepeat abuse across channelsNever alone; it ties the other controls together
Fraud detection toolsRisky orders, friendly fraud patterns, linked accountsOrder volume is too high to review by hand
Reverse logistics checksItem swapping, empty-box and decoy returnsYou sell high-value or serialized goods

These tactics fit into a broader ecommerce fraud prevention strategy that covers threats beyond refunds alone. To act earlier, learn how to detect return and refund abuse before shipping an order.

How do you prevent refund fraud without hurting the customer experience?

State when you release funds. For a high-value item, you may need to inspect the return first. Follow the return terms and deadlines that apply to the sale.

Write the rules into your policy so honest buyers know what to expect. Then improve your return policy with clear time limits, condition rules and proof requirements.

Should you refund or fight a suspected refund fraud claim?

  • Refund when the amount is small, the customer has a clean history and you lack evidence.
  • Fight when you have delivery proof, usage data or intake photos that contradict a friendly fraud or return claim.
  • Do not refund under threat if a chargeback is already filed. A refund at that point can lead to a double loss.

{{cta}}

Check for an open case or a completed credit before sending money. Know the difference between a refund and a reversal transaction so you can trace the right payment.

If a dispute opens, match the claim to the return tracking, inspection and credit records. The issuer decides the case.

Chargeflow Automation charges a share of the amount it recovers. See its success-based pricing for current terms.

Chargeflow's Products

Catch Risky Orders Before You Ship

Chargeflow Prevent scans orders after checkout and before fulfillment.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
White circular logo with interlocking shapes at the center surrounded by overlapping orbit-like elliptical lines and scattered blue diamond shapes.

Chargebacks?
No longer your problem.

Recover 4x more chargebacks and prevent up to 90% of incoming ones, powered by AI and a global network of 20,000 merchants.

600+ reviews
No credit card needed.
subscribe

The latest chargebacks, fraud, and ecommerce content, in your inbox. Every week.

Sign up now and never miss out the latest trends!
By providing your email you're agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Notice
Diagram with dashed and curved lines forming segmented arcs highlighted by three blue diamond markers on the left side.Abstract circular grid design with blue diamond markers on a half-black, half-white background.